*Sorry for the long post, the details are really for myself to remember, but hopefully they will be of help to someone else.
Jon and I decided it was time to get serious about potty training. I had read a few things here and there about different methods and taken several "readiness" quizzes to make sure Hadley was ready. According to all the quizzes she was showing signs of being ready. The only thing we weren't real sure of was her physical development as far as being able to control it all herself. I don't think a parent can really know that before trying things out though. This was one area of parenting I felt like there had to be some specific secret formula. My biggest hurdle was figuring out how to teach Hadley to listen to her body, so to speak. It seems like such an abstract idea to teach a toddler. So off we go.
We decided we'd start real slow and just have her sit on the potty like three times a day, wearing pull ups. We were careful to give a statement, "Let's go sit on the potty," instead of asking a question, "do you want to go sit on the potty?" Because inevitably she would say no if given the option, she was too busy playing. She hardly EVER put up a fight when we just said it. We also got a bag of M&M's as a reward (or rather motivation) for sitting on the potty. She got 1 M&M for just sitting there, then if she actually went we'd give her a handful. We'd keep her there as long as we could usually 2-3 minutes by reading books, singing songs, talking, anything we could think of.
I had read about the method of letting the child run naked, allowing them to feel more of what was going on, thus training them faster. A lot of friends had also recommended this method with success stories to back it up. I was leaning more toward trying this, for some reason drastic methods seem to work well for our family, like our sleep training did. However, just to feel things out, Jon and I decided to take it slow, besides the naked method suggested blocking out 3 days of staying at home and focusing on only that and this month (of our own accord) has been packed full of things to do so we weren't sure how we'd do it.
The first week didn't involve any successes. Jon and I were still trying to get ourselves in the habit of remembering to get her on the potty and it seemed she was holding out until the pull up was back on or we were timing it wrong. It just wasn't working. I was sharing it all with my mom when she mentioned she used cotton training pants for my brother and I. They're like the next step between cloth diapers and underwear, I'd highly recommend them to anyone who is in the middle of potty training. So the next day I went to Babies R' Us and bought 6 pairs thinking the different feeling of the cotton underwear would help. The only bad thing about using the training pants for the initial days of training are they fit snugly around the legs to prevent anything from falling out (which is great) but it makes it more difficult if you're rushing to get the kid on the potty mid-pee. Yes, I speak from experience. Hadley wasn't real excited about the feeling of peeing in the training pants but it didn't seem to be enough motivation to get to the potty before peeing.
I then went to the library and picked up a book called
Potty Wise, by the same people who wrote
Baby Wise of which method we used for sleep training. I read through it and realized it offered a few different approaches, one being the fast track method. The one big difference between the book and our current approach was rewarding the child for staying dry instead of "using" the potty. Ugh, that makes sense, but I wasn't sure how to make the transition. She didn't seem to catch on too quickly about staying dry but we forged ahead nonetheless.
Here is where I was about to lose faith, thinking maybe we were pushing her too soon. She wasn't putting up much of a fight to sit on the potty but again, she didn't seem to care enough to get to the potty. This brings me to today. A friend came over to hang out for a bit this morning so I decided to just stay home for the day. This afforded us the opportunity to go naked! Well Hadley went bottomless at least after our friends left, but she kept her training pants on while they were over. Twice she peed in her training pants and seemed uncomfortable but still wouldn't get to the bathroom in time. After our friends left I stripped her down and let her run naked. She seemed completely unfazed by the whole thing.
It was nap time, and without any success I put her in a diaper and laid her down for a nap. After she woke up we sat on the potty and ran naked again. About two hours later she wanted to go outside so I we tried the potty again and nothing. I put her training pants on with some shorts and outside we went. Not 5 minutes later she peed in her pants again! We changed them and then she was fine. Once inside we stripped her down again and after dinner and a few more attempts on the potty she ended up peeing on the floor in our master bathroom. She definitely did not like that! Later on in the evening she started grabbing herself and holding her legs together, much in the fashion of a typical potty dance, so I picked her up and ran her in the bathroom. Nothing. She got up, did the potty dance again, I ran her to the potty again, and nothing.
Jon walks in the bathroom while she's sitting on the potty. He started running the water (which we've tried several times before with no success) and Hadley wanted to get up and play with the water in the sink. Jon told her she had to pee first before she could play in the water. We walked out to give her some privacy and not 15 seconds later I hear her, "mommy, I peed!" She's also said this before when it wasn't true so I was expecting to see an empty potty but alas, SHE HAD PEED! Hallelujah! She really wanted to play in the water. She was so proud of herself and we jumped up and down, she got a whole cookie for herself and we called Nanaw and Papa to tell them.
Who knew playing with water in the sink would be a great motivator. Hadley wanted to play with the water so much she tried so hard to pee just 10 minutes after doing it the first time. But by-golly if she didn't do it again before bed time (without us prompting her) so she could splash in the sink. That's it for now. She's no where close to being fully potty trained but the success of tonight has given us great hope. There just might a be light at the end of this potty-training tunnel.
I still plan to use the training pants as she becomes better at using the potty because they have a more absorbent middle than regular underwear, but until we're more consistent with using the potty, naked it is!